[fosscomm] Spoken Tutorial Project - IIT Bombay, Interest in getting involved with you !
narendra at narendrasisodiya.com
Mon Oct 17 23:38:57 PDT 2011
On Tue, Oct 18, 2011 at 10:49 AM, <jtd at mtnl.net.in> wrote:
> On Tuesday 18 Oct 2011 02:23:05 Vivek Khurana wrote:
> > On Mon, Oct 17, 2011 at 11:11 AM, Narendra Sisodiya
> > <narendra at narendrasisodiya.com> wrote:
> > > show me some example where CC-By content got exploited !! Its like "SEA
> > Remember the case of Kalyaan Verma's photo being used in TOI ?
Kalyaan Verma licensed under "NC" terms and conditions -
So it was illgally used by TOI.
That was not my question.
I want a case where a Profit making LALA kind of business man exploited a
Non-NC work. I guess this in the only worry a person has which provoke him
to use NC clause.
If "Kalyaan Verma" would have used CC-By or CC-by-SA and then imagine TOI
used it for PROFIT then may someone calculate that how much extra money TOI
will get to its revenue just because of Kalyaan Verma's photos.
If Kalyaan Verma want that nobody should get a single paisa with using his
photos then he would have used "ALL Right Reserved, Permission granted only
to see it in this form and copying/saving and doing anything else is not
> > > WATER", any body is allowed to commercialize it but who will purchase
> > > ? There might be some good person who can setup a purification unit of
> > > water and want to sell it Or sell a normal water to a person who is
> > > living 20KM from "SEA WATER". in both case, they are getting they are
> > > money out of their services !
> > Maybe if we were living in a world driven by principles of Zen and
> > Buddha economy, your arguments will hold true. But this is a
> > capitalist world where you might be charged for "SEA WATER" if someone
> > can figure out the ways to make it useful and control the access to
> > "SEA WATER". You cannot charge for "SEA WATER" because there is no use
> > for it, but you can charge for "GANGA JAL", "WATER FROM SPRINGS" and
> > "PACKAGED TAP WATER". How do you think the business of bottled water
> > works ? Everyone buys bottled water while drinking water is available
> > everywhere...
> > > See Video of NPTEL !! Gods knows their licences ! they charges heavy !
> > > Imagine they licence it under CC-By, I/Somebody will jump into selling
> > > those Videos. I can sell 500 GB video preloaded harddisk or just 400GB
> > > full video repo to many many colleges and students. student are ready
> > > buy them because they connot download it.
> > Ignorance is rarely a bliss... See here
> > http://nptel.iitm.ac.in/availability.php (Individual's section)
> Truly. Next time check for licence, not marketing blather.
> > regards
> > Vivek
> network mailing list
> network at lists.fosscom.in
│ Narendra Sisodiya
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the network